Amendure v. Jenny Jones Show is one of the most unique and devastating cases I've ever researched. Below is the timeline of events:
PRECEDING MARCH 6TH, 1995: The Jenny Jones Show planned an episode where people would meet their secret admirers. Jonathan Schmitz was invited to participate, but was not told that the admirer involved in his segment would be a man.
MARCH 6TH, 1995: Scott Amedure (32) appeared on The Jenny Jones Show in Chicago as Schmitz's secret admirer. Schmitz initially appeared relatively composed on camera, but afterward expressed that he felt embarrassed and humiliated by the episode.
MARCH 6TH-9TH, 1995: The episode was never broadcast, and in the following days Schmitz faced more intense emotional reactions.
MARCH 9TH, 1995: Schmitz travels to Amedure's home and kills him, subsequently prosecuting him for the killing.
1995-1998: Schmitz was convicted of second-degree murder, but his initial conviction was overturned because of issues regarding jury selection, leading to a new trial. Ultimately, he was convicted again and received a 22-year sentence for the murder. He was released in 2017 for "good behavior".
Following 1995, Amedure's estate sued Warner Bros., Telepictures, and the Jenny Jones Show, arguing that the producers' conduct surrounding the taping contributed directly to Amedure's death.
MAY 7TH, 1999: A jury sided with Amedure's family, awarding approximately $29.3 million in damages.
OCTOBER 22, 2002: The defendants appealed, and the Michigan Court of Appeals reversed the jury's judgment and ordered judgment for the defendants. The court held that, under these circumstances, the show and its producers didn't owe Amedure a legally cognizable duty to protect him from Schmitz's homicidal actions.